And TIFF'12 is well underway!The first film that I saw this year was The We and the I (trailer here). The synopsis of the movie seemed to be interesting because of the subject matter, but the actual description of way the movie would be presented wasn't that compelling to me. From the synopsis, I wasn't completely sure if it would be a documentary or feature film. Nonetheless, I decided to give the movie a chance. The fact that Michael Gondry was the big name associated to the film didn't really make a difference to me. I didn't see any of his previous films.
The movie basically takes place on a public transit bus departing from a high school on the last day of school before the summer holiday and ends as the last couple of students get off and start their break. During the bus ride, we meet different students who all attend the same school and have been on the same bus line for the entire year. We see their interactions and their stories that seem very much 'high school'.
My review of the film...well, I found it okay, but nothing too special. It seemed like I was just watching real life unfold, but since I can witness real life on a daily basis and have lived through adolescence and see adolescence often in my life, the film didn't seem to enrich anything for me. The 'actors' did seem sort of amateur at times and that didn't help matters. I don't usually notice inconsistencies in films, but the fact that I noticed that the time of day and weather around the bus changed randomly from scene to scene might be an indication that I wasn't completely invested in the story. And although each of the storylines were independently interesting, at times I felt it a little jarring how the filmmaker(s) transitioned between them.
Now here's the thing that wants me give the film the benefit of the doubt. This film spawned from a project between Gondry and the 'actors' as an afterschool program. In fact, the 'actors' are students, and from a final piece in the closing credits, we get a sense that the film is inspired by the students and that Gondry was really invested in these students and made a big impact on their lives. I imagine that the students were asked to share topics that were important to them and they helped developed the screenplay. However, I did notice that in the opening and closing credits, Gondry was credited a lot and the students just (?) seemed to be listed as the actors and there was just (?) a small mention of the project.
I was very disappointed that no one from the film attended the screening. I would have been interested to learn a little bit more about the project and what the main message of the film was. I really left this screening wanting to know a little bit more. It was the first screening of the film at the festival, so I had thought there would be folks from the film in attendance, but it didn't work out that way. There wasn't even a message passed along to the programmers to pass along to us. What a disappointment.
So, not quite a rave review, but I like the idea that this film started from a project with students. I just wish the film could have been a wee bit more, I don't know. Something.
- picture courtesy of www.tiff.net







